Geometry Project - Kite Shapes

by Jayden
(Oklahoma City, OK, USA)

Q:

Both a square and rhomboid (diagonal) kite are perpendicular to the wind. They both have effective areas. What shapes would those be? And whats the difference from the effective areas?

And where on a box kite would I tie string to get the greatest effective area?

A:

After a little research I was able to figure out what you are actually asking :-) I believe you are enquiring about differences between the traditional square Box kite and the slighly flattened version called the Rhomboid kite?

The geometry question only makes sense if the Rhomboid kite is just the Box kite with the bracing cross-pieces changed in length. To put it in a non-mathematical way, imagine the square Box kite is 'squashed' so the cells look diamond-shaped instead of square. Of course, both kites have exactly the same amount of sail area.

The question states that both kite designs are placed perpendicular to the wind. Let us imagine that they are sitting on their tail ends on the ground too, and being held there, ready to launch. Just down-wind of the kites is a large smooth wall. It is night time and the kite-flier, way upwind, is shining a very bright light towards the kites. CASTING SHADOWS ON THE WALL.

These shadows can represent the effective areas of the kites. Both shadows will show 2 rectangles for each kite. An upper and a lower one, corresponding to the upper and lower cells of the kites.

But look - the Rhomboid kite is casting wider shadows than the Box kite! Since the heights of all the shadows are the same, what does that mean? It means the Rhomboid has a larger effective area than the Box, despite having the same amount of sail material covering it. If it is stopping more light from hitting the wall, it must also be a bigger obstacle for the air flowing around it!

If you did a little trigonometry, you could calculate the exact difference in effective area between the 2 kites. Ask another question if you would like that explained in detail. Of course, kites cannot fly perpendicular to the wind, so in real life the effective areas are smaller.

I hope all this helps to make the concept of 'effective area' a little clearer.

Regarding the last part of your question, about getting the largest effective area for a box kite... You would tie the string to the exact middle of one of the long main spars. But of course, the kite wouldn't fly! You could perhaps toss it out the back of a drag racer as an air-brake ;-)

One more comment... It's funny that the Rhomboid Kite has that name, since technically the cell shape is a Rhombus. That is, a shape with all 4 sides of equal length. A Rhomboid is the more general case where adjacent sides are of unequal length. That is, 2 sides have one length and the other 2 sides have another length.

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to About Kites.




E-book special of the month (25% off)...

Click to get 'Making The MBK Parachute Kite'

This printable e-book takes you step-by-step through making a 119 cm (4 ft) wide Parachute kite. It's not quite that wide in the air since the canopy takes on a distinct curved shape when inflated. This 14-cell kite performs best in moderate to fresh wind speeds. That's 20 to 38 kph or 13 to 24 mph. In gentle winds, this kite will hang in the air at fairly low line angles. In fresh winds, it pulls firmly for it's size, so small kids should only fly it while supervised!

Every kite design in the MBK Soft Series satisfies the following points...

  • Materials are plastic sheet, tape and line – and nothing more!
  • Tools are a ruler, scissors and a marker pen - and nothing more!
  • All cuts are along straight lines.

For the greatest chance of success, I make recommendations regarding the materials. For example, the type/weight of plastic, type/width of tape and line type/strength. Close enough should nearly always be good enough, since the design is well-tested and should be tolerant of small differences from my original.

Get the e-book for making the MBK Parachute kite. After making your first one in plastic and seeing how it performs, you can try soft Tyvek or rip-stop nylon for your next build.

The e-book is a PDF file - which means printable instructions to refer to while you make the kite. It also means convenient off-line access if that suits you better.



What's New!

  1. Rokkaku Kite

    Aug 16, 17 06:00 AM

    This previously published page is full of general info on this type of kite, including some history. With a video clip and a good photo, it's worth checking out...

    Read More









 


E-books


Kite-making e-book: Simplest Dowel Kites

This one's FREE
Download it now!



More E-books...





Testimonials
(unedited)

"Love the easy to understand step by step instructions, made from next to nothing materials and above all so much fun to fly... cheers Tim for sharing your well thought out pdf kite designs with the whole world.

Very satisfying making your own and watching them get air-born for the first time."

_________________

"I decided to run kite making as an elective again on this camp in the past week - so I bought all your e-books, a bunch of materials, and then took a group of 10 high school students through making the kites over 4 days. We built a diamond, a Barn Door, a Delta, and two skew delta kites. Again - every single kite flew."

_________________

"I've just bought your super e-book and spent most of last night pouring through all the great stuff in it!

Very detailed and USEFUL information - thanks for such a great book."

_________________

"30+ years ago, I tried making a kite using the 'instructions' in a free kite-safety booklet. What a disappointment for a young boy.

 Your instructions and methods are wonderful. You help the builder to focus on accuracy, without making it hard. Also, you use materials that are durable, yet cheap!"

_________________

"omg i made a kite from this site and i fly it ....... booom i didnt expect this bc in the other sites instuction are trash

thank you"




Kite-making e-book: Simplest Dowel Kites

This one's FREE
Download it now!



More E-books...





Wind Speeds


Light air
1-5 km/h
1-3 mph
1-3 knots
Beaufort 1

Light breeze
6–11 km/h
4–7 mph
4–6 knots
Beaufort 2    

Gentle breeze
12–19 km/h
8–12 mph
7–10 knots
Beaufort 3    

Moderate breeze
20–28 km/h
13–18 mph
11–16 knots
Beaufort 4    

Fresh breeze
29–38 km/h
19–24 mph
17–21 knots
Beaufort 5    

Strong breeze
39–49 km/h
25–31 mph
22–27 knots
Beaufort 6

High Wind
50-61 km/h
32-38 mph
28-33 knots
Beaufort 7